The consequences of privatization for Swedish welfare have been discussed for many years, especially concerning elderly care. Today, about 20 percent of all residential care homes are run by non-municipal actors. A new study shows that these actors succeed differently at delivering high-quality care to the elderly.
"Residential care homes run by non-profit organizations have the highest quality. The lowest quality is provided by residential care homes run by publicly traded companies and private equity firms. In between these are residential care homes run by private limited liability companies," says political scientist Rasmus Broms.
He, together with two other political scientists, Carl Dahlström and Marina Nistotskaya, has investigated how the form of operation affects the quality of non-municipally run residential care homes in Sweden. The researchers compared four different forms of operation: non-profit organizations, private limited liability companies, publicly traded companies, and private equity firms. They examined staff density, access to nurses, staff education level, resident satisfaction, and how well the homes updated their action plans. The analyses are based on 2,639 non-municipal nursing homes between 2012 and 2019.
The results thus show that non-profit organizations such as ideologically driven operations generally provide the highest-quality elderly care in Sweden. These do not engage in profit distribution but reinvest their financial surplus in the business.
"Here we see the highest staff density, many nurses, the most competent care staff in terms of education, and the most satisfied users."
Among the profit-making care companies, quality is highest in homes run by private companies. These homes are characterized by high staff density and the staff are generally better educated compared to homes run by companies that are publicly traded or owned by private equity firms.
"Although we have not studied municipally run facilities more closely in this survey, we see that municipal residential care homes in terms of quality are in between those run by non-profit organizations and private companies. Our analyses show that non-municipal actors can deliver high-quality welfare services but that there are significant variations. This is worth considering when a municipality procures the operation of a home," says Rasmus Broms.
